A schoolgirl in Novosibirsk, Russia, was apprehended for stealing instant noodles from a supermarket, leading to a heated discussion among local residents about the appropriate response. Store employees detained the girl and contacted the police, as seen in a video where she is held on the floor while resisting.

The incident has elicited nearly 400 comments from Novosibirsk residents, with opinions divided between those who advocate for punishment and those who sympathize with the girl.

Many residents believe that while severe punishment is unwarranted, an educational conversation is necessary. One reader emphasized the importance of educational work to prevent future offenses. Another commentator argued that leniency could lead to children becoming spoiled and lacking boundaries.

Some suggested involving the juvenile delinquency department and having guardianship authorities assess the child’s living conditions, raising concerns about potential food insecurity.

Others speculated that the girl’s actions were not driven by hunger, but rather by other factors. One anonymous commenter supported calling the police to investigate the underlying reasons for the theft.

Conversely, some residents criticized the treatment of the teenager as overly harsh. An anonymous commenter pointed out that the value of the stolen goods was minimal and that involving the police was an overreaction.

Some commentators attributed the girl’s behavior to a lack of constructive activities for teenagers, suggesting that boredom and a lack of engagement in youth organizations may have played a role. They described it as a game of “dare” resulting from teenagers being idle.