Roman Rotenberg’s dismissal from all positions within SKA has sent shockwaves through Russian hockey, eliciting a range of responses from coaches and journalists alike. While some laud his systemic approach and contributions to the club, others point to his perceived overreach and the team’s recent lackluster performance.

Several coaches have expressed regret over Rotenberg’s departure, emphasizing his role in transforming SKA into a powerhouse. Vladislav Tretiak, President of the Russian Ice Hockey Federation, acknowledged the disappointing season but credited Rotenberg with creating an exceptional training system that attracted players and fans alike. Vladimir Krikunov echoed this sentiment, praising Rotenberg’s energy and managerial skills, while Vyacheslav Fetisov acknowledged the inherent risks of the coaching profession and expressed confidence in Rotenberg’s future endeavors. Alexander Kozhevnikov even went so far as to call him the “brightest coach in the KHL.” Maxim Rybin admitted surprise at the dismissal, noting ongoing preparations for the upcoming season.

In contrast, journalists offer a more critical perspective, highlighting a decline in results and questioning Rotenberg’s managerial approach. Commentator Dmitry Guberniev, while acknowledging Rotenberg’s dedication and contributions, conceded that SKA’s performance had stalled. Alexander Kavokin pointed out that the dismissal marks a turning point in Rotenberg’s career, while Daniil Ratnikov detailed the team’s gradual decline under his leadership. Damir Bulanov argued that Rotenberg’s rejection of checks and balances and his tendency to assume control over all aspects of the club ultimately led to his downfall. Dmitry Erykalov suggested that a break and a reassessment of his approach would be beneficial. Daria Tuboltseva, deems Rotenberg’s departure the end of an era, attributing his downfall to unlimited power and the inability of one person to manage all aspects of the organization.