The GroenLinks-PvdA party is facing internal conflict over a motion regarding Israel’s Iron Dome defense system. The disagreement arose during a congress meant to celebrate the merger of the GroenLinks and PvdA parties, highlighting a deep division within the newly unified left-wing movement.

The motion, proposed by MP Kati Piri, suggested halting the supply of parts for Israel’s Iron Dome as a means of pressuring Prime Minister Netanyahu to negotiate. This proposal has sparked considerable controversy, challenging the long-held view that Israel has the right to defend itself. Critics argue that questioning Israel’s security could exacerbate the conflict, as past violence has often stemmed from a sense of insecurity.

Party leader Frans Timmermans acknowledged the validity of both sides of the argument but failed to broker a compromise that would satisfy all factions. Instead, the issue was decided by a majority vote, leaving a significant portion of the party feeling unheard and causing considerable pain, particularly among members like Lodewijk Asscher and Job Cohen.

The handling of this disagreement raises concerns about the party’s ability to effectively address internal divisions and maintain unity. Critics suggest that a more inclusive approach, focused on finding solutions that address the concerns of all members, is necessary to build a broad left-wing movement. This internal strife also casts doubt on the party’s ability to form a strong coalition to address the violence in Gaza.